šŸŽ‚ Zim Now turns 4 on July 16, 2026
News

Gappah criticises judge for siding with Mahere in US$50k lawsuit

Zim Now WriterLawyer and author, Petinna Gappah has accused Justice Jacob Mafusire of favouring her opponent, politician prominent lawyer Fadzayi Mahere, in a defamation lawsuit.Gappah is representing...

E
Eddie Zvinonzwa Contributor
|
Published 7 June 2024 • 3:39 am
|
Updated 16 November 2026 • 11:48 pm
|
Read time 5 min read
Tags #Zimbabwe #Business #Turnall

Zim Now Writer

Lawyer and author, Petinna Gappah has accused Justice Jacob Mafusire of favouring her opponent, politician prominent lawyer Fadzayi Mahere, in a defamation lawsuit.

Gappah is representing herself in the case, in which Mahere is demanding US$50 000 in damages over tweets that Gappah posted about her.

ā€œI need clear instructions on why Mahere is allowed to reference statements I retracted and if I do so I get blocked,ā€ Gappah protested to the judge.

The judge responded: ā€œYou don’t seem to appreciate my directive. You’re the one who keeps asking questions that make the plaintiff go back to the same statements. Your cross-examination is all over and I don’t see us finishing. You need to confine your cross-examination to issues raised in evidence in chief.ā€

Gappah had earlier apologised and retracted her tweets, which Mahere alleged had damaged her reputation and demanded US$1 million. She reduced the amount to US$50 000 this week, citing that Gappah’s apology was insincere.

ā€œOf course I am a lawyer, but because of the perceptions I will be called an unscrupulous lawyer. An apology has been issued and some statements retracted, but the defendant still maintains that the statements are true,ā€ Mahere told the court.

Mahere added: ā€œIt is the ā€˜how I rise’ that was affected. Everyone believes that I cheat my way to the top, that is irreparable harm.ā€

Gappah argued that her statements did not harm Mahere’s career, citing her continued success in law and politics.

ā€œShe was appointed spokesperson for MDC Alliance and Citizens Coalition for Change respectively, despite what I said about her. She was also elected as a legislator for Mt Pleasant constituency among other achievements,ā€ Gappah said.

The judge adjourned the case indefinitely, stating that the proceedings had become a ā€œfarceā€.

Gappah will file her closing submissions on June 17, while Mahere will file hers by July 1.

 

Eddie Zvinonzwa

About Eddie Zvinonzwa

Staff Writer