Police order fresh probe into alleged four-year stepdaughter rape case
Police have ordered a comprehensive review of investigations into a case in which a 40-year-old Harare man is accused of sexually abusing his stepdaughter.
Police have ordered a comprehensive review of investigations into a case in which a 40-year-old Harare man is accused of sexually abusing his stepdaughter over a four-year period, following concerns raised by the victim’s family and highlighted in a report published by Zim Now.
The intervention by the Zimbabwe Republic Police (ZRP) comes ahead of the accused’s scheduled trial on December 1, with authorities recommending that the entire investigation be revisited to ensure that outstanding evidence and procedural gaps are addressed and a comprehensive docket compiled.
Simbarashe Kandeya, 40, is accused of repeatedly sexually abusing his now 17-year-old stepdaughter from the time she was 13 and in Form One.
The alleged abuse came to light after the girl’s mother, having become suspicious of her daughter’s behaviour, approached the school head to establish what could be wrong. The teenager subsequently confided in the school head about the alleged sexual abuse.
The matter was reported to Epworth Police Station, where investigations were initiated and statements recorded before the case was subsequently referred to Mbare Magistrates’ Courts.
However, concerns over the handling of the investigations, raised by the victim’s family and brought to public attention through this publication, prompted further engagement with senior police officers at the District Victim Friendly Unit (DVFU) at Harare Central Police Station.
Among the family’s principal concerns was the accused’s release on bail, particularly given that police had reportedly spent nearly two months trying to locate and apprehend him, eventually resorting to a trap to secure his arrest.
The family also complained that it had not been adequately informed about the bail amount and conditions imposed by the court.
Further concern arose over alleged attempts by Kandeya, following his release, to establish contact with the victim’s mother and grandmother, raising fears of possible interference with witnesses.
The family also questioned discrepancies in the accused’s residential details contained in the court documents. While the typed State outline reportedly described him as having no fixed abode, an address had subsequently been handwritten onto the document, prompting questions about when and under what circumstances the amendment was made.
Other concerns centred on the omission of a statement from a witness who allegedly observed one of the incidents of abuse, as well as questions surrounding the preparation of the victim impact assessment, both of which the family considers important to the prosecution's case.
The family maintains that the victim impact assessment was completed hurriedly on the day of the court appearance, while the parties were waiting for a police vehicle to transport them to Mbare Magistrates’ Courts.
It argues that the circumstances did not afford the teenager sufficient time or privacy to adequately express her experiences and the impact of the alleged abuse.
During engagements with the DVFU at Harare Central yesterday, the family was reportedly given the option of having the matter handled at district level or having the entire investigative process reviewed.
It was subsequently referred to Mbare Magistrates’ Courts for further engagement with the prosecutor in charge.
Following the consultations, it was resolved that investigations be revisited in their entirety, with the identified omissions and concerns addressed ahead of the December 1 trial date.
Meanwhile, it has since been established that Kandeya was granted bail of US$100, with one of the conditions being that he must not interfere with witnesses.
The developments underscore the importance of institutional accountability and the media's public watchdog role in bringing matters of public concern to the attention of relevant authorities, particularly where the protection of vulnerable victims and the integrity of the justice process are at stake.
About Gilbert Munetsi - Correspondent
Staff Writer