War vets await Springs Farm ruling after government reopens land case
War veterans await a High Court ruling on Springs Farm after government reopened a case over the withdrawal of their land offer letters.
War veterans and their families at Springs Farm in Goromonzi are awaiting a High Court judgment in their fight against the withdrawal of agricultural offer letters, after government successfully reopened their earlier court victory.
Justice Tshuma reserved judgment following a virtual hearing on Monday, November 16. A ruling is expected on Thursday, November 19, according to an update provided to Zim Now.
The applicants are Joseph Macheka, Alfred Chademana, Tamo Hove Muza, Mangisai Katsande and Unico Chikomo. They are challenging the Lands Minister’s June 2024 decision to withdraw their agricultural offer letters for subdivisions of the Goromonzi farm.
Their earlier court victory has already been set aside. In a judgment dated May 21, 2026, Justice Chitapi rescinded Justice Regis Dembure’s 2025 judgment and granted the minister additional time to submit opposing papers.
The earlier judgment followed the exclusion of an opposing affidavit submitted by the ministry’s permanent secretary. Justice Dembure held that the official could not explain, on the minister’s behalf, the reasoning behind the administrative decision under review.
Justice Chitapi subsequently found that the resulting judgment was susceptible to rescission and that the minister’s default had not been wilful.
“The interest of justice will be served if this case is determined holistically after hearing both the applicant and the respondents,” he ruled.
That decision reopened the farmers’ review application without finally determining whether withdrawal of their offer letters was lawful.
In the subsequent opposing affidavit, Lands Minister Vangelis Peter Haritatos argues that condition seven of the offer letters authorised their withdrawal and that converting Springs Farm to urban use serves a wider public purpose.
He says the property borders Harare and Umwinsidale and is suitable for urban expansion.
“The Applicants’ representations did not outweigh the public purpose of urban development which will benefit a greater number of people,” the affidavit states.
The minister disputes the farmers’ contention that their objections were inadequately considered. He says ministry officials met them and that their representations resulted in offers of compensation for permanent improvements or alternative land.
The farmers, meanwhile, contest the withdrawal on grounds including illegality, procedural unfairness and irrationality. Their objections concern investments on the land, existing farming agreements and whether they should participate in its proposed development.
A representative says the beneficiaries are pursuing their own development plans through Sovereign Spring Properties.
“We feel black people are capable of doing world class property development on the land they are settled,” the representative told Zim Now.
Minister Haritatos’ affidavit also raises a preliminary objection that the Local Government Ministry should have been joined to the proceedings because the land had been handed over to it for urban development. The minister argues that selecting developers subsequently fell within that ministry’s responsibility.
The wider dispute involves a June 5, 2025 deed recording the transfer of approximately 671.6 hectares to Marimba Residential Properties Limited, a company linked to businessman Billy Rautenbach. The deed describes the award as compensation.
The farmers dispute the basis for that compensation, citing earlier Aspindale litigation which they say undermines Marimba’s ownership claim over the land for which it is supposed to receive replacement property. Their objection therefore concerns both the withdrawal of their own offer letters and whether the competing compensation claim was legally justified.
About Michael Mashiri
Staff Writer