Utility vehicle issue clouds magistrate's High Cou...

Utility vehicle issue clouds magistrate's High Court bid

Philemon Jambaya

ASSISTANT EDITOR

Beitbridge magistrate Innocent Bepura’s bid for a High Court judge position hit a snag during public interviews after it was revealed he once used a Judicial Service Commission vehicle without permission.

The incident came to light following a traffic accident involving the vehicle. Bepura faced a grilling from a panel including Chief Justice Luke Malaba, Judge President Mary Zimba-Dube, and Commissioner Katsande.

Bepura admitted the misconduct, calling it “uncalled for” for a judicial officer. He claimed he wasn’t aware of a policy requiring permission to drive a JSC vehicle after an accident. However, he acknowledged needing to “be more compliant”.

Further scrutiny came from Commissioner Katsande, who questioned if Bepura was truly unaware of the guidelines. Bepura insisted this was an isolated incident and he strives to stay up-to-date on legal requirements.

Chief Justice Malaba pressed Bepura on what would have happened if there wasn’t an accident. Bepura’s explanation, about attending a hearing related to the vehicle damage in Gwanda, raised further concerns.

Bepura also faced criticism regarding his experience, having only served in magistrate courts of smaller cities. When questioned by Commissioner N Moyo, Bepura defended his readiness for a High Court role, emphasising the consistent application of law across locations. However, his responses appeared to frustrate the commissioner.

Later, Judge President Zimba-Dube inquired about the biggest challenges Bepura anticipated as a judge. Bepura cited workload but assured his dedication to completing the task at hand.

Another candidate, Muneinazvo Chitakunye, a commercial lawyer with no judicial experience, struggled to define “inherent jurisdiction” during his interview. Despite lacking judicial background, Chitakunye argued his commercial experience provides valuable diversity and shouldn’t disqualify him.

Evans Chivayo Naison, a former prosecutor and police officer, was also among the interviewed candidates.

The interviews mark the initial stage of selecting new High Court and Administrative Court judges.